I've been wearing Fox's "Cheap" boots (Trackers) for trail riding and I'm amazed at well they work.
I have a different Philosophy than most. I don't keep boots for very long nowadays. Usually 1 to 1 1/2 years at most. I've learned an important lesson...Boots aren't suppose to be "Soft and Supple". They're protection. Period. They, obviously, need to be comfortable; HOWEVER, they're supposed to be protecting your feet and ankles.
When they start to "SoftenUp" and get floppy...they're GONE!
I wear Formas for the Track/Racing (It's a Bubba Thing!) and Trackers for the Trail/Desert. The Trackers have a great sole/tread for those slimmey trail conditions. At the races/track I DON'T want that traction when I put my foot out for the turns; Hence, the "One-Way" tread/sole on the Formas.
If you ride A LOT...2 pairs of boots are better AND cheaper than 1. ALWAYS let your boots air out until THEY ARE DRY. It's healthier for your feet and your boots will last longer.
Good luck,
Manny