Most all of the aftermarket plastic is good stuff (Acerbis, Polisport, UFO) and holds up as well as the OEM stuff. If your bike has been outside for a while, the sun will "Bleach" the color out and will look very dull. The only plastic I will not buy, is the Maier brand, it is vacuum formed opposed to the other companies injection molded (far superior process). If your plastic is an Off color it could be the Flo-Green color which is alot more of a Neon looking color.