I've bottomed out my suspension so bad that I blew the bumpstop out of the shock.
It felt like my fillings popped out
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8415b/8415b03a34972eca555f2ca613ccfaacb5faa058" alt="smiley :-)"
My arrestor has never touched the brake caliper.
I do have lots of skid marks on the inside of my fender.
Can you post some pics of your arrestor, fender, rear wheel, rear caliper areas?