As far as I know...nothing is wrong with my current carb. It's a little scraped up which honestly bothers me a bit but not enough to replace it. However, that is not my main reason for wanting to swap it out. My main reason is that I want this bike to be as "brand new" as possible for a 13 year old bike. So, if I can get an important part like that brand new for $150 bucks...it seems to me like a small price to pay for peace of mind as far as my carb goes. The more brand new parts I put on this bike, theoretically, the less parts I will have to comb through if there are any issues when the build is done.
i.e. If the bike doesn't run or start once it's all back together, I'll know it's not the carb (theoretically). Either that or I don't know wtf I'm doing as far as jetting. But you know what I mean.
I want this bike to run as if it were 2000 and I just bought it brand new. And I want it to last for a good 6 or 7 years.
Also, to me, there is something exciting about starting from a clean slate. When I got the bike it looked like someone mistreated it for a long time and I personally have a thing for new, shiny, mint condition things haha (I'm kind of anal retentive)
Starting with a brand new carb out of the box, ordering the jetting kit, jetting it to whatever specs we find suitable, and then putting it on the bike just makes it more gratifying when I stand back and stare at my finished product for 2139808124 hours. haha